Feature Requests

Transcription timing accuracy is poor for music even for voice-only track
The auto-transcription performance for songs or voice tracks (lyrics) is not good and need to be improved to be practically useful/effective, at least based on our testing, and in comparison with other auto-transcription online services. Following multiple tests including with auto-transcription, separating music vs voice and using voice-only track for transcription, importing the song lyric (transcript), we found that the transcription timing accuracy error rate is so significant that it cannot function efficiently and would require too much manual transcription. In contrast, other auto-transcription online services that we have been using can perform this without issue, almost getting the timing always accurate, even with both instrument + voice combined track. Typically the only minor corrections needed are only for the words/spelling/punctuation marks, but almost never for the timing. In Descript, the timing is always significantly off at various places, sometimes even impacting a big chunk of the lyric text. We have consulted Descript support and arrived at this conclusion. We understand that this is not really the primary use-case for Descript as we were advised. However we are submitting this feature request as it could be helpful for other potential users as well, it would be good if Descript can improve the transcription performance for this use case. We were interested in exploring Descript especially with the innovative script/storyboard/scenes interface that seems nice, however unfortunately the lack of auto-transcription effectiveness is a significant problem. Thank you.
0
·
Transcription
Improve punctuation so it follows the rules of grammar
I would say at least half of the edits I need to make for my transcripts are fixing issues that Descript introduces because it does bizarre things with punctuation and random capitalization of words like you, somebody, some and that after commas. Can you stop it from adding a comma every time a presenter pauses to gather their thoughts? I that's why we see extra commas, and commas in the wrong places like after an "and" or "or" or "of" instead of before one. Regardless of whether that's the cause, grammatically those commas need to come before those words, not after them. A bigger issue is it throws in commas and periods in places that would never have them. There is zero reason that there should ever be period after the words "the", "and" or "or" because humans don't end sentences with these words, but the transcripts are littered with them, and each needs to be removed. There are only a few cases that there should be a comma or period after the words "to" and never a period or comma after "a" and not only are there tons of both in transcripts, you also can't do a search and replace since you decided to only allow find whole words on words 3 letters/characters or longer! Yes, I can search for them without selecting the match the whole word filter, but when I'm looking to replace "a," it also picks up every time there's a "trauma," which is quite often considering the topic of our lectures. Also, why does it separate prefixes from the words? We don't write about re experiencing things or non compliance or co workers, but Descript renders prefixes that way and all of those need to be fixed too, as well as insisting on adding a space after the period in numbers with decimals, and both a comma and a space to all numbers in the thousands or higher, which is not how humans write either. More recently, within the past couple of months, there are a bunch of periods showing up in inappropriate places within the middle of sentences (not immediately before or after a pause, mind you, but within fluidly spoken sentences) that even Descript seems to realize are not correct, because it doesn't capitalize the next word after these periods, which ironically makes them harder to spot given the marker to indicate a pause between words looks somewhat similar to a period. I've been using this program for 3+ years, and it's frustrating how little attention transcript issues like this are still given. The AI features are great, but maybe you could get AI to fix the punctuation issues while you're at it?
0
·
Transcription
Load More